
The German Federal Bureau of Maritime Casualty Investigation (BSU) has highlighted the importance of comprehensive maintenance of the clutch system following an incident involving a fire due to overheated clutch igniting accumulated oil.
What happened?
While a ship carrying passengers was underway, a fire broke out in the vicinity of a main engine clutch. The fire detection system alerted the bridge and the engineer officer on watch. Two crewmembers opened the engine room access door, encountered dense smoke and fire, and closed the door again.
The water mist system was activated and additional sprinklers were switched on manually. These systems extinguished the fire before the prepared firefighting team began a direct attack. The team then continued cooling the affected area. The main engine concerned was shut down and assistance was requested from shore. The ship returned to its port of departure with tug and pilot assistance. No one was injured.
The investigation
The clutch had been slipping during operation, generating substantial heat. According to the investigation findings, this heat ignited oil that had accumulated around the clutch and beneath its cover. The oil came from a leaking cylinder lubrication system. Examination of the clutch itself revealed no damage that had initiated the fire.
The pneumatic remote-control system used to control and monitor the clutch was not fully functional. If the air pressure is too low, the system is designed to disengage the clutch automatically to prevent it from transmitting torque while slipping.
The investigation identified several factors:
- One hose had become disconnected from a control valve; the valve itself was functional. Another hose, connected to the pressure-reducing valve, was damaged and leaking. Only when the hinged mounting plate was closed did it become apparent that this hose was sharply bent at its connection. In addition, a valve in the air pressure monitoring system had a continuous leak. According to the manufacturer, this could cause intermittent switching failures.
- It could not be conclusively established which factor arose first or how the individual factors interacted. The report attributes the clutch slipping to the pneumatic system not being fully functional. The accumulated oil provided the combustible material for the fire.
- During the investigation, the shipping company arranged for the cylinder lubrication systems to be replaced, oil leaks to be rectified and the engine room to be refurbished, among other measures.
Lessons learned
In its report, the BSU included the following lessons learned:
Include the entire clutch system in maintenance. Inspections should cover the pneumatic controls, hose connections, valves and protective functions as well as the clutch itself. A mechanically undamaged clutch can slip and overheat as a result of faults in its control system.
Check hoses with the mounting plate closed as well. After replacement, check hose routing and connections throughout the full range of movement. Closing the plate must not kink or pinch hoses or place strain on their connections. Follow the manufacturer’s routing instructions.
Carry out specific leak tests and checks of protective functions. Air leaks can go unnoticed in a noisy engine room. Appropriate leak tests and functional checks in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions must also cover pressure monitoring and automatic disengagement at insufficient air pressure.
Track identified defects through to rectification. Keep traceable records of maintenance findings, required component replacements and subsequent functional checks. Ordering a spare part alone does not demonstrate that the defect has been rectified and the protective function restored.
Rectify oil leaks and remove concealed accumulations. Include areas beneath clutch covers and other locations that are difficult to access in inspections for accumulated oil. In addition to cleaning, eliminate the source of the leak. Heat generated by friction can also ignite accumulated oil.
Keep fire detection and fixed firefighting systems ready for use. Crew members must know the activation points and operating procedures and practise them regularly. In this case, the water mist system and additional sprinklers extinguished the fire at an early stage. Subsequent cooling and monitoring of the affected area helped ensure that the fire remained extinguished.