
A surveyor drowned after falling into the sea while transferring from a bulk carrier to service boat off Singapore earlier this year.
In its investigative report, the BMA highlighted in its conclusion that “There have been a significant number of deaths of surveyors, technicians, superintendents and ship’s crew during transfer between ships and boats but the risks do not seem to be apparent to the industry. Much work has been done to improve awareness of requirements and implement universal standards for pilot transfer arrangements but this has not extended to others that face the same hazards.”
The BMA also identified 10 recent similar cases from the data available in the IMO’s marine casualty and incidents database in their Global Integrated Shipping Information System.
Surveyors, technicians, superintendents and ship’s crew have fallen into the sea whilst attempting to transfer between ships and boats. In almost all cases the victim was not wearing a lifejacket. In many cases the victim was wearing a backpack. In all the cases the service/transfer boat was unable to rescue the person in the water.
What happened
On the evening of 17 January 2026, the Bahamas-flagged bulk carrier, Nightlife, was at anchor off Singapore. Whilst the ship’s crew were preparing for diving operations and mooring a bunker barge alongside, a bunker surveyor was transferring to a service boat, SG Naav, using Nightlife’s accommodation ladder.
During the transfer, the bunker surveyor fell, landing heavily on SG Naav’s deck. The boat’s two crew tried to pull him on board but he fell into the sea. Despite in-water assistance from one of the boat’s crew and a diver from a nearby workboat, it required assistance from a Singapore Police Coastguard vessel to retrieve him from the water.
Once recovered, he received cardio-pulmonary resuscitation whilst on passage to shore but was declared dead when he arrived at hospital. A post-mortem indicated that he drowned.
Why it happened
- Nightlife’s large freeboard, use of a forward-leading accommodation ladder and removal of the outboard stanchion increased complexity of the transfer. The rolling and pitching of SG Naav made it more difficult for the victim to safely complete the transfer.
- As the victim’s lifejacket was not effectively secured, it was lost and could not afford him any buoyancy. The combination of the design of SG Naav and unavailability of any man overboard recovery equipment meant that the victim could not be recovered to SG Naav.
- At the time of the casualty, there was significant time pressure on Nightlife’s crew. Personnel on deck and on the bridge were tasked with several conflicting operations that affected the selection of transfer arrangements, reduced the available number of crew to facilitate the transfer and reduced the perceived importance of the personnel transfer. None of the operations were subject to effective assessment of the risks posed, either individually or collectively.
What we can learn
A significant number of personnel have been killed during transfer between ships and boats but the risks do not seem to be apparent to the industry.
Much work has been done to improve the standards for pilot transfer arrangements: the industry would benefit from reframing of the language used when referring to these arrangements to ensure that all personnel subject to the hazards present when transferring are offered the protections required by SOLAS Chapter V, Regulation 23.
The timing of the many operations being conducted at anchor was not under the influence of the crew. When planning calls at busy maritime hubs, charterers and ship managers need to identify what activities may clash or overstretch onboard resources and put measures in place to mitigate the potential additional risks created.
Broadcasting a ‘Mayday’ message on the appropriate channel using standard marine communication protocols increases the likelihood that nearby vessels are made aware of a situation where they may provide assistance.
Download the report: